9 Awful Reasons Adopters Return Their Dogs To Shelters

Nov 15, 2025bySarah McConnell

Every year, countless dogs find themselves back in shelters after being adopted. While some returns happen for understandable reasons, others are downright shocking. The excuses some people give reveal a troubling lack of commitment to their furry friends.

This article discusses difficult realities about pet returns. The goal is to raise awareness and encourage more responsible adoption practices.

1. The Dog Grew Too Big

The Dog Grew Too Big
Image Credit: © Matthias Zomer / Pexels

Puppies are adorable, but they grow up fast. Some adopters return dogs because they didn’t realize how large their furry friend would become. A little research before adoption could prevent this heartbreaking situation.

Breed characteristics are easy to find online or by asking shelter staff. If you live in a small apartment, consider adopting a smaller breed or an adult dog whose size is already known.

2. Shedding Was Too Much to Handle

Shedding Was Too Much to Handle
Image Credit: © Goochie Poochie Grooming / Pexels

Dog hair on furniture, clothes, and floors drives some people crazy. Believe it or not, excessive shedding is a common reason for returns. Regular grooming and vacuuming can manage this issue effectively.

Different breeds shed at different rates. Poodles and schnauzers shed minimally, while huskies and golden retrievers shed year round. Knowing what to expect makes all the difference in long term happiness.

3. The Dog Didn’t Match Their Furniture

The Dog Didn't Match Their Furniture
Image Credit: © Domingos Moreira / Pexels

Yes, you read that correctly. Some adopters have returned dogs because their colour clashed with home décor. This shallow reasoning shows a complete misunderstanding of what pet ownership means.

Dogs are living beings with feelings, not accessories to match your sofa. If aesthetics matter more than companionship, perhaps a stuffed animal would be a better choice for your home.

4. Training Required Too Much Effort

Training Required Too Much Effort
Image Credit: © Pixabay / Pexels

Every dog needs training, but some people expect perfectly behaved pets without putting in work. When their dog jumps, barks, or has accidents, they give up instead of seeking help.

Professional trainers and online resources make learning easy. Most behavioural issues can be resolved with patience and consistency. The bond you build through training makes every moment worthwhile.

5. They Had A Baby

They Had A Baby
Image Credit: © Sarah Chai / Pexels

Starting a family should mean expanding love, not eliminating existing members. Many people return dogs when they become pregnant or have a newborn, citing safety concerns that are often unfounded.

With proper introductions and supervision, dogs and babies can coexist beautifully. Countless families raise children alongside dogs without any problems. Planning and preparation prevent unnecessary heartbreak for everyone involved.

6. The Dog Got Sick Or Injured

The Dog Got Sick Or Injured
Image Credit: © Tima Miroshnichenko / Pexels

Medical emergencies happen, and vet bills can be expensive. Sadly, some adopters return their dogs rather than providing necessary care. Pet insurance and emergency savings can prevent this difficult choice.

Many veterinary clinics offer payment plans for unexpected expenses. Animal welfare organizations sometimes provide financial assistance for medical treatments. Abandoning a sick pet when they need you most is truly heartbreaking.

7. Moving To A New Home

Moving To A New Home
Image Credit: © Ketut Subiyanto / Pexels

Relocating presents challenges, but ditching your dog shouldn’t be the solution. Some people return their pets because their new landlord doesn’t allow animals or their new place is smaller.

Pet friendly housing exists everywhere if you search diligently. Making your dog a priority during housing searches ensures they remain part of your family. True commitment means finding solutions, not excuses.

8. The Novelty Wore Off

The Novelty Wore Off
Image Credit: © MART PRODUCTION / Pexels

Impulse adoptions often end badly when the initial excitement fades. After a few weeks or months, some people realize pet ownership involves daily responsibilities they didn’t anticipate.

Dogs need feeding, walking, playtime, and attention every single day. They’re not toys you can put away when bored. Thinking seriously about long term commitment before adopting prevents devastating returns later.

9. Allergies Suddenly Appeared

Allergies Suddenly Appeared
Image Credit: © Karola G / Pexels

Discovering pet allergies after adoption happens, but many people don’t explore solutions before returning their dog. Allergy medications, air purifiers, and regular cleaning can reduce symptoms significantly.

Allergy testing before adoption helps avoid this situation entirely. For mild allergies, simple management strategies work well. Severe cases are understandable, but exhaust all options before making this difficult decision.