Creatures That Fooled Us Into Thinking They Went Extinct

Sep 17, 2025byEmily Dawson

Nature has a fascinating way of surprising us. Sometimes, animals we thought were lost forever suddenly reappear, defying our assumptions about their extinction. These remarkable creatures managed to hide from scientific observation, often for decades or even centuries, before making their dramatic comebacks. Their rediscovery not only excites the scientific community but also gives us hope for other species we might have prematurely declared extinct.

While these animals were rediscovered after being presumed extinct, conservation status can change rapidly. This information is current as of publication, but readers should verify the latest conservation data when referencing these species for research or conservation efforts.

1. Coelacanth

Coelacanth
©Image Credit: Catmando/Shutterstock

Believed extinct for 65 million years until a fisherman hauled one up in 1938 off South Africa’s coast. Scientists were astonished – this prehistoric fish with lobed fins was thought to have vanished with the dinosaurs!

Today, these rare, blue-tinged creatures still swim in deep ocean caves, growing up to 6.5 feet long and weighing 200 pounds. Their discovery ranks among zoology’s most dramatic comebacks.

2. New Caledonian Crested Gecko

New Caledonian Crested Gecko
Image Credit:© Peter Law / Pexels

Presumed extinct until a tropical storm in 1994 blew several into researchers’ paths! These adorable lizards sport distinctive eyelash-like crests and toe pads that let them climb virtually any surface.

Their rediscovery caused a sensation in the pet trade, ironically helping save them. Their ability to leap between trees and change color slightly helped them hide from science for decades.

3. Chacoan Peccary

Chacoan Peccary
©Image Credit: Artush/Shutterstock

Scientists only knew this pig-like creature from fossils until 1975 when living specimens were discovered in Paraguay’s remote Gran Chaco region. Local indigenous people had always known about the “tagua,” but science had declared it extinct for thousands of years!

These social animals live in groups of up to 20, sporting salt-and-pepper fur with a distinctive white collar around their necks.

4. Omura’s Whale

Omura's Whale
©Image Credit: Ethan Daniels/Shutterstock

Never technically declared extinct because scientists didn’t even know it existed as a separate species until 2003! Previously misidentified as a smaller version of Bryde’s whale, these 33-foot cetaceans had been hiding in plain sight.

With distinctive asymmetrical coloration – dark on the right jaw, white on the left – these sleek whales cruise tropical waters worldwide. Their discovery reminded scientists how much remains unknown in our oceans.

5. Takahe

Takahe
Image Credit:© Timo Volz / Pexels

Declared extinct in 1898 after hunting and introduced predators decimated populations, this colorful flightless bird was rediscovered in 1948 in a remote New Zealand valley. A doctor on a hiking expedition spotted one and recognized it from museum specimens.

With beautiful blue-purple plumage and a massive red bill, these chicken-sized birds survive today only through intensive conservation efforts. Fewer than 500 remain in protected areas.

Emily Dawson
byEmily Dawson

Toronto-based freelance writer and lifelong cat lover. Emily covers pet care, animal behavior, and heartwarming rescue stories. She has adopted three shelter cats and actively supports local animal charities.